PDA

View Full Version : Pace's "Best of" threads #23: Power supply



Pace
10th October 2002, 17:17
Just saw everyone's favourite chip designers talk about his favourite PSU, and I was chatting the other day to another MURCer about this. Now then, what's your opinion on the best PSU? The last time I bought a PC I made a few bad choices (1 was an Abit motherboard, the other was Abit capacitors, the other was Abit...etc), and I later added an Enermax PSU. Now, I think we all know about Enermax's slightly dodgy output, but if not them, then who? I don't know many PSU brands beyond Enermax, Sparkle spring to mind.

And another question which I'm sure will be discussed anyway, are branded PSUs more reliable? My fellow MURCer had two "quality" PSUs fail, and generic run for years on end. What are your experiences? Interesting to note I've had two PSUs fail - one last week on my rackmount case (reliable my ass), and another in a local company, who purchased that much loved PC Chips brand...motherboard, case and PSU the lot :(

Anyway, thoughts before I replace the rack PSU? :)

P.

thop
10th October 2002, 17:27
i am more than happy with my ZALMAN (see sig). don't let the 300W fool you! also it's very quiet (i enhanced it though to make it noiseless :)). it wasnt exactly cheap though or more precisely: they are a bit overpriced.

Wombat
10th October 2002, 18:18
For the good price/quality point, Sparkle supplies are pretty good.

If you're willing to spend, and know that you're getting top quality, PC Power & Cooling.

ZokesPro
10th October 2002, 18:23
I've always had a standard PSU and now I have an enermax and I'm happy with it.

rugger
10th October 2002, 21:05
Aopen power supplies have always been realiable for me.

They have also been able to handle amazing loads.

Athlon XP 2000+ with a 250W power supply anyone :D

DirtFarmer
10th October 2002, 21:27
I Love my PC Power & Cooling Silencer 400 all most as much as I Love my G400.
Now I'm going upstairs to jump in bed with my Wife :) :)

Tempest
10th October 2002, 23:42
Antec.

Edit: Though I haven't had any problems with my 430W Enermax or 300W Fortron/Source either.

mutz
11th October 2002, 00:15
I've noticed and heard there are lots of labels and PSU mods, and under them is a Channel Well, and I think someone here said Antec was a CWT too...

luni
11th October 2002, 00:25
I must also say Antec. Enermaxes are eye candy, but their output is flaky at best.

Tempest
11th October 2002, 00:40
Originally posted by mutz
I've noticed and heard there are lots of labels and PSU mods, and under them is a Channel Well, and I think someone here said Antec was a CWT too... Yep, all PSUs that carry "case manufacturer" brands (Antec, Enlight, AOpen etc) are renamed. In best case they are Channel Well or Fortron, in a worst case scenario... Let's not get into that :)

RichL
11th October 2002, 00:42
Had a 250w PSU badged Arrowana for years, no problems.
Built my new rig with a 300w AMD reccomended Micron PSU. The PSU blew up within a few weeks.
Replaced it with an Enermax 350w - no problems whatsoever.

GNEP
11th October 2002, 02:09
Generic 300W: fine for me, if a little noisy (and probably due for a good ol' clean). But would go for a nice, stable, good value 400+W one if I needed to swap it out - so this thread is an excellent idea!

KvHagedorn
11th October 2002, 03:01
If you want a real tank of a power supply, get a PCPower and Cooling. I have a PCP&C turbo-cool 450w in my main machine (dual P3-600, 3-10k SCSI hard drives, etc.) I run the thing day and night, and this computer never hiccups.. ever.

I'm getting another one for my gaming box. Hey.. you can't afford the best CAR.. but you could afford the best PSU.. it's worth it.

Nuno
11th October 2002, 07:10
Generic crap 300W :)
ECS K7S5A, XP1600+@1800+, 2 Crucial 256Mb DDR sticks, volcano7+, seagate 7200rpm 40 gb, samsung dvd combo, LG 24x burner, floppy, case fan, Geforce4 Ti4400, sb audigy, NIC card.

Electric Amish
11th October 2002, 07:17
My Sparkle 300w has been trustworthy for the last 2 years.

amish

Wombat
11th October 2002, 08:10
I have a Fortron/Source. They are modified Sparkle units.

Jammrock
11th October 2002, 09:41
PC Power and Cooling makes great power supplies. They are expensive.

Jammrock

Pace
11th October 2002, 09:53
Any other suppliers for PC Power and Cooling besides direct from them (www.pcpowerandcooling.com)? Ideally UK :)

Otherwise there'll be a bunch of Sparkle's on their way to my door.

P.